Review one candidate's response for a recurring B2B paid-social creative production engagement. Use only the pasted specification, response and supplied attachments. Do not browse unless asked.

Apply these rules: public or proposal language supports only its exact claim; a promised document is Unknown until inspected; a portfolio does not prove capacity or performance; a polished final does not prove source-file delivery; a general turnaround claim does not prove this workload's clock; and a weighted score cannot override a Must-have Fail or Unknown.

BUYER SPECIFICATION AND HARD GATES
[PASTE]

CANDIDATE RESPONSE
[PASTE]

SUPPLIED ATTACHMENTS OR MISSING-ATTACHMENT LIST
[PASTE]

Return: (1) exact evidence received with source pointer; (2) Must-have states using Pass, Fail or Unknown; (3) contradictions between the response, attachments and buyer scope; (4) operational gaps covering definitions, capacity, revision rules, clock rules, duration and delivery milestones, team coverage, sources/licenses, naming, measurement and offboarding; (5) disposition Shortlist, Hold for evidence or Exclude; (6) a candidate-specific follow-up table with field, exact question, requested proof, owner and due date; and (7) contract language that must be made testable before signing. Do not invent a missing fact or calculate a final weighted score while any Must have is Unknown.